When it comes to timeless cocktails, few drinks can match the sophistication and depth of the Old Fashioned, Boulevardier, and Manhattan. These three classics have stood the test of time. Each offers a unique blend of flavors that caters to different palates. Whether you love whiskey cocktails, enjoy bitter-sweet complexity, or appreciate a perfectly balanced cocktail, these drinks belong in your repertoire. Let’s dive into the history, recipes, and tips for crafting these iconic cocktails. Click on each image for the full recipe of these Bourbon or Rye cocktails!
Comparing the Three Whiskey Cocktails
While all three cocktails are whiskey-based, they each offer a unique drinking experience:
- Old Fashioned: A Bourbon cocktail, simple, strong, and whiskey-forward. Perfect for purists.
- Boulevardier: Bitter-sweet and complex, with a touch of herbal richness. Great for Negroni lovers.
- Manhattan: Smooth, sophisticated, and balanced. Ideal for those who enjoy a touch of sweetness.
The Old Fashioned
History
The Old Fashioned is often considered one of the oldest known cocktails, dating all the way back to the early 1800s. This drink is an iconic Bourbon cocktail. Initially, it was simply called the “whiskey cocktail,” and it was traditionally made with spirits, sugar, a splash of water, and bitters. However, over time, it evolved into the Old Fashioned we know today, a drink that not only celebrates the purity of whiskey but also does so with minimal interference.
Why It Works
The Old Fashioned is all about simplicity and balance; therefore, the sweetness of the sugar, coupled with the bitterness of the bitters, along with the richness of the whiskey, come together in perfect harmony. Furthermore, the orange twist adds a bright, aromatic finish, enhancing the overall experience.
Use a high-quality bourbon or rye whiskey, as it’s the star of the show. A large ice cube melts slowly, preventing dilution and keeping the drink strong and flavorful.
The Boulevardier
History
The Boulevardier closely resembles the Negroni, but whiskey replaces gin in this cocktail. Harry McElhone, a famous bartender in Paris, created it in the 1920s and named it after Erskine Gwynne, an American expatriate and publisher of a magazine called The Boulevardier.
Why It Works
The Boulevardier not only combines the boldness of whiskey with the bitter-sweet complexity of Campari but also incorporates the herbal richness of sweet vermouth. Moreover, it’s a sophisticated drink that’s perfect for those who enjoy a delicate balance of bitter and sweet.
Experiment with different types of whiskey to see how they change the flavor profile. Rye whiskey adds spiciness, while bourbon brings a sweeter, smoother note.
The Manhattan
History
The Manhattan is undoubtedly one of the most iconic whiskey cocktails, with a history that dates back to the late 19th century. Interestingly, legend has it that the drink was created at the Manhattan Club in New York City for a banquet hosted by Winston Churchill’s mother. Whether or not the story is true, it is important to note that, over time, the Manhattan has subsequently become a symbol of elegance and refinement.
Why It Works
The Manhattan is a study in balance. The spiciness of rye in this cocktail pairs beautifully with the sweetness of vermouth, while the bitters add depth and complexity. The cherry garnish adds a touch of sweetness and visual appeal.
Use high-quality sweet vermouth, as it plays a key role in the drink’s flavor. For a drier version, try a Perfect Manhattan instead, which uses equal parts sweet and dry vermouth.
From visitors