Choosing between a suitcase and a backpack for traveling depends on several factors, including the nature of the trip, personal preferences, and the type of activities planned. When I went to Canada, I took a 40-liter suitcase as I knew I needed some winter clothes which were quite bulky. This suitcase allowed me to pack extra layers, such as thick sweaters and insulated jackets, ensuring I was prepared for the cold weather. The sturdy wheels made maneuvering through airport terminals a breeze, and the spacious compartments helped keep my belongings organized. However, for Australia, I opted for a 68-liter backpack as I was taking lighter clothes and was going to be moving around a lot more. The backpack provided the flexibility to easily transition from urban exploration to outdoor adventures, allowing me to hike with ease while still having everything I needed for the trip. In this case, the convenience of a backpack outweighed the capacity of a suitcase, as it facilitated a more dynamic travel experience.
So backpack or Suitcase?
While there is no right answer, picking your luggage is the first step for packing for any trip. You need make a choice so you know how much you can pack and make sure you align your decision with your airlines baggage allowance. Think of what type of trip you might be making. Will you be in one place for a long period of time or moving about every few weeks? Can you fit everything you need? What kind of transport will you be taking? Or will you be walking a lot?
Here’s a comparison to help decide what might be better for you:
Suitcase
Advantages:
- Ease of Packing: Suitcases generally open wide, making packing and organizing easier. They often have multiple compartments which is ideal for separating items.
- Protection: Hard-shell suitcases provide more protection against damage and weather conditions.
- Mobility: Equipped with wheels, they can be easier to transport in airports, hotels, and paved streets.
Disadvantages:
- Weight: Suitcases can be heavier, which might be a disadvantage when walking long distances or where there are no elevators.
- Size: Larger suitcases might be cumbersome in crowded areas and may incur extra fees if checked on airlines.
68 Liter Backpack
Advantages:
- Flexibility: Backpacks are more versatile and easier to carry over different terrains, making them suitable for adventure travel, hiking, or locations with lots of stairs.
- Storage: Large capacity backpacks like the 65-liter size are excellent for carrying a lot, particularly useful for extended trips.
- Hands-Free: Traveling with a backpack allows your hands to be free, making it easier to get through train stations and airports
Disadvantages:
- Comfort: Carrying a heavy backpack for a long time can be physically challenging and might not be suitable for everyone.
- Accessibility: Getting items from a backpack can be less convenient than from a suitcase since you often have to unpack layers to reach what’s at the bottom.
Considerations
- Trip Duration: For shorter trips, a backpack might be more convenient. For longer trips, a suitcase can offer more space and organization.
- Destination: If you’re traveling to urban areas with smooth surfaces, a suitcase is ideal. For more rugged or remote destinations, a backpack is better.
- Personal Preference: Consider your comfort and how you prefer to carry your belongings
There are plenty of other factors to consider as well. One being security. Most suitcases will have a dual zip that meets in the middle. With a loop for a lock to go through. In a way having a suitcase is like carrying around a safe. You can then keep all your important belonging locked away when you don’t need them. It is much harder with a backpack. You could but multiple locks and do a similar thing but it would be much easier to break into or even just rip the fabric. Consider your accommodation. Most hostels will provide lockers where you can store valuables but if they don’t a suitcase could be the way to go.
Conclusion
The choice between a suitcase and a backpack ultimately depends on your travel style and destination. If your trip involves multiple locations, varied terrains, or public transport, a backpack may be better. It allows for easier maneuverability and keeps your hands free to navigate crowded spaces. Plus, backpacks often have compartments for organized packing, making them ideal for adventurous trips needing quick access to essentials. On the other hand, if most of your travel is in urban areas or you need to carry delicate items, a suitcase might be the better option. A suitcase with wheels makes transport easy on paved surfaces. Suitcases generally protect fragile belongings better and can hold more items when packed neatly, which benefits longer trips or occasions requiring different outfits. Therefore, considering your journey’s nature, accommodation type, and packing needs will help you make the best decision for your travels. For more on packing and luggage check out how i packed for Australia or 8 essential carry on items.
